Lying With Headlines About the Climate

As one of the most powerful liars in the world, Matt Drudge takes perverse pleasure in twisting facts to fit his right-wing denialist agenda. He’s got this down to a fine art, cherry-picking and sometimes re-writing actual headlines from newspapers around the world. He editorializes by the way he groups stories, often making it seem like there is a groundswell of evidence for his tea-party talking points. It’s a hell-in-a-handbasket approach, with breathless exploitation of every possible logical fallacy (which gets him a direct line to the paleo-Republican amygdala). Add a dose of mean-spirited schoolyard taunts, and you have the essence of the Drudge Report.

All that hyperbole gets him tens of millions of page-views daily and a virtual lock on the news cycle. Proving that a free press is not much of a guarantee of anything, except that those who shout what people want to hear in the loudest voice control the conversation.

Drudge can be counted on to trumpet every major or minor storm. Never mind what’s happening with the climate, he locks his jaws onto every degree of winter weather like it was a hunk of red meat. ‘RECORD STORM BLANKETS MIDWEST…BLIZZARD…ICE STORM…CHILL MAP…THOUSANDS WITHOUT POWER. “See, I told you so!” And if some climate protest ever gets snowed out, he’ll tell you all about it with self-righteous derision. When nature turns on the oven, and it’s above 40 Celsius (104 F) like it has been in Australia the past day or so, Drudge is silent.

His usual cherry-picking is bad enough. But today, that was punctuated by something even more insidious–outright lying. How do you lie with a headline? By grouping it with others and fostering deliberate semantic confusion about the facts.

Here’s the headlines:



What a bunch of buffoons!!!! Right?

The first headline linked to a story in Science Daily.

Wow, I thought, that’s unusual, since it’s well-known that CO2 has gone from pre-industrial levels around 265 ppm to the current 389 ppm. What’s up? I was expecting to read about how thousands of scientists had all collectively made an error in measurement, were now correcting it, and “the whole of climate science is being re-evaluated.”


The story is talking about the percentage of atmospheric carbon which remains in the atmosphere (about 45 percent) vs. that which gets absorbed by the ocean and other carbon sinks. As atmospheric CO2 concentrations have risen, what this means is that 55% of it is still being absorbed. That is expected to change as the oceans become saturated with the gas. So not only will ocean acidification get steadily worse, but the oceans will eventually lose their ability to absorb carbon altogether.

Drudge can read, he knows damn well the headline doesn’t mean what it seems to imply, yet he ran it anyway. If there is a definition of failed journalistic ethics, this is it. I’d go a step further and call it just plain evil.

From Science Daily:

However, some studies have suggested that the ability of oceans and plants to absorb carbon dioxide recently may have begun to decline and that the airborne fraction of anthropogenic carbon dioxide emissions is therefore beginning to increase.

Many climate models also assume that the airborne fraction will increase. Because understanding of the airborne fraction of carbon dioxide is important for predicting future climate change, it is essential to have accurate knowledge of whether that fraction is changing or will change as emissions increase.

To assess whether the airborne fraction is indeed increasing, Wolfgang Knorr of the Department of Earth Sciences at the University of Bristol reanalyzed available atmospheric carbon dioxide and emissions data since 1850 and considers the uncertainties in the data.

In contradiction to some recent studies, he finds that the airborne fraction of carbon dioxide has not increased either during the past 150 years or during the most recent five decades.

Given the stakes, what this study really means is that we have to be even more careful because we might be nearing a tipping point at which the oceans suddenly become saturated. At that point we would get more than a doubling of the portion in the atmosphere, leading to a non-linear increase and even faster temperature rise than expected. We really need to know if this is going to happen. If it does, it’s a problem so huge as to not even be able to be expressed in financial or human terms. The changing of the chemistry of the seas, which make up 3/4 of our planet’s surface poses an existential threat like no other. Essentially what this study documents is the incredible service we’ve enjoyed. Our oceans have at no cost removed over half of the human CO2 pollution from the atmosphere for the last two centuries.

This is something vital to our continued existence, and it may halt or reverse at any time. We need to know when that time might be, and we should all be very concerned in a very personal way about reaching it.

But thanks to Drudge, the GOP can toast the new decade tonight in blissful ignorance of our peril, because there’s been “no increase in the atmospheric carbon fraction.”

This website uses IntenseDebate comments, but they are not currently loaded because either your browser doesn't support JavaScript, or they didn't load fast enough.

Comments (39 comments)

GMNightmare / January 31st, 2010, 3:12 pm / #1

Hmm… Wait, where is your proof? Where is anybodies proof? “I studied how CO2 fluctuated…” Why does everybody only have graphs?

Because your lying, but you don’t know that. They are lying, and your just mindlessly copying what they say. It’s high time people quite just looking at phony statistics that any student who went to college and took a class on statistics could distort. Number 1 rule baby, correlation does not cause causation.

This is very simple, how much heat does CO2 add to the Earth? No, no doomsday prediction articles that give some absolutely bull graph. Tell me, how much would Earth’s temperature would change if the CO2 levels went to 1200 ppm? Can you tell me that? It’s a really small number, to give you a hint.

CO2 is about the only good thing we are doing to our environment, and yet it’s treated like an evil thing and covers all the bad, say, for example the real reason our oceans are in trouble and acidifying, plastic landmasses. Ignore what is the real problems with environment and blame it all on one scapegoat right? Wouldn’t actually want to research what really happens to things, no, lets put up some graphs and say all our problems concede with the raise of CO2, so it must be that.

Let’s give an example:

“the ability of oceans and plants to absorb carbon dioxide recently may have begun to decline”

So you mean to tell me, say, for plants, the air they must be able to breath, CO2, is causing them to not be able to breath? Are you just not thinking for one second past what you are told? I mean seriously, you buy that BS? Sorry, but increased CO2 in the air, will actually be a boon to plants.

I’ll tell you why it’s on the “decline”, it’s because we keep chopping down all the plants and terraforming land to make our houses and roads and whatever else the hell we want. Sound like a problem? Hell yeah. But let’s just blame CO2 shall we? Ocean absorbtion? I covered that, but let’s go over again, do you think having a layer of plastic covering our oceans has an effect on that?

Activists and zealots constantly shrilling over atmospheric carbon dioxide are misdirecting attention and effort from real and potentially addressable local, regional and planetary problems.

Clark / January 31st, 2010, 10:34 pm / #2

So, what you're saying is… if the writer of the article concludes that:

"the airborne fraction of carbon dioxide has not increased either during the past 150 years or during the most recent five decades"

it is inaccurate for Drudge to title his piece:



Yeah… I guess I can see that. If you are predisposed to hate Drudge and you twist reality around until it fits YOUR agenda. Yep. Then, it makes sense to think that the article title is misleading.

Here, where I reside, in the real world, the article title is practically a quote from the article. What it "implies" is subjective. That you saw it as you did says a lot more about you than it does Drudge.

reverse phone lookup / March 4th, 2013, 4:36 pm / #3

Really interesting and special post. I like things such because making more homework,
developing writing skills, and also related things.
These kinds of secrets help in being a qualified person on this topic.
This page is very helpful to myself because people for instance you committed time to learning.
Regularity is the key. In spite of this it is just not too effortless, as has been designed to be.
I am not an expert something like you and a whole lot of times I feel really giving it

testdomain / March 17th, 2013, 10:43 am / #4

hello I was quite impressed with the setup you used with this internet site. I use blogs my self so very good job. definatly adding to bookmarks. 404295

David R Gray / October 4th, 2014, 10:16 am / #5

Article writing helps us to express our feeling on any topic. That is the reason many people try to write more on their issues and for their solution. If you get services of dissertation writing or get the best content from articles it will help you to make your studies easy.

Bimana / November 23rd, 2014, 9:39 am / #6

Obvious parallels to Mahatma Ghandi. The Climate have a lot in common with Schrödinger's cat in their "the end is nigh" attitude. I'm wasting my time here. HVAC learning ? Who woulda thunk it? BlackSun has put the cart before the horse. In fact he has put all of the carts before the horse.

essay writer / December 21st, 2014, 6:29 am / #7

Without a doubt, Kayaking and Canoeing are few of the most fun-filled bold games that need an enormous physical work expertise. These two dauntless brave exercises include the exercises that are very nearly eco-accommodating. Being the game for the populace of all age ranges, it is recognized and ensured as a pleasant fun filled act. It is one of the most ideal ways that give space for investigating and encountering the embodiment of immaculateness and common magnificence of the nature's domain with a bundle of fun skip and experience.

waleedmoayad / February 19th, 2015, 7:25 am / #8

A number of people in United Arab Emirates are working in industry since years and are facing halt in their career growth because lacking academic excellence and due to this reason they are now opting the online bachelors degree in UAE to continue their studies without facing any hurdle in their work routines.

Apple Ibeacon / March 10th, 2015, 7:37 am / #9

This site inspire me a lot by the religious news and post. I came to to know also a lot of unknown facts here.

tysonmark / April 26th, 2015, 12:18 am / #10

Stunning article. I was simply scanning for something else on Bing and arrived on your site. You've put some magnificent exertion into getting this up.

Seaside Real Estate / May 6th, 2015, 4:11 am / #11

I would and stimulate upright about each specimen to store this tangle attendant for some dearest assistance to aid posted the guise.

essay writer / June 13th, 2015, 2:52 pm / #12

Likewise we need to make a subject about the use of money and make it compulsory for students as they cannot complete their degree without reading this subject. So that in this way might help people in getting out from the race of brand.

clothing factory / August 11th, 2015, 4:46 am / #13

hello I was quite impressed with the setup you used with this internet site. I use blogs my self so very good job. definatly adding to bookmarks. 404295

Doris Tracey / August 31st, 2015, 12:08 pm / #14

Why is there so much confusion regarding climate change? Why are we so divided and unable to know the truth? I was taught that climate change comes from the sun. Yes, we are polluting this world big time. Mother earth should use centrifugal force to spin us all off the planet and give birth to new united creatures. We are definitely not an integrated group of people tied to a higher consciousness. We are a very psychologically sick group of people. This is why the planet is in distress.

rob / September 21st, 2015, 1:46 am / #15

Entirely great facts! I’m on top of that an experienced in this issues i want to file we are able to easily discover your overall. weight loss vest

Pinhan / September 21st, 2015, 10:40 pm / #16

Well the transitions that have been occurring lately are so vivid and with no pattern, it has made it pretty difficult to note the changes that are yet to come in advance. It has always been a tough task in understanding nature. Do not underestimate it.Port Window Glass Manufacturer

admin / September 23rd, 2015, 2:49 am / #17

To boost money to start business is not as difficult as most people appear to think. This is especially true when you have an idea that may make you and your backers rich.

rob / October 1st, 2015, 4:07 am / #18

That had been wonderful to recognize to look at. Be cautious on the way to wonderful write-up. Exclusive most in comparison with of which… Crecen what actually a great write-up We now have reached learn as well as arrive at think everybody About just about any beneficial as well as observing with an trip genuinely presently there for that reason a similar kind of write-up intended for not long ago each week as well as barely showed up ordinary several. End up being happy tremendously that find more content by means of a person. wooden height chart

rob / October 1st, 2015, 4:30 am / #19

End up being happy on the way to incredibly affordable assess. Many people & the exact neighbors’ appeared growing to be getting ready to get numerous dilemma which experts claim. All everybody acquired an amazing principle interior whereby stuff by means of community magazine as well as numerous e-books whereby a lesser number of have an impact on nevertheless your computer details. Thermal Imaging Surveys

alsiah / October 1st, 2015, 9:23 pm / #20

In home maintain companionship enable you to supplement active senior proper care services, or it is usually used as being a compassionate approach to help conserve the mental along with emotional health associated with an elderly individual that has number of companions.Home Move

alsiah / October 1st, 2015, 9:23 pm / #21

Home Design Design - Make designing the house decor must not be a high priced undertaking. Household accessories along with decor, you are able to nevertheless always be great in most materials so as to complete your energy yourself.Home Decoration

alsiah / October 1st, 2015, 9:23 pm / #22

An interior designer is primarily responsible to the inner planning, decoration, and functionality of the clientâEUR(TM)s place and always in concert with architects along with clients to learn the structure coming from a space.Interior Design and Decorating

alsiah / October 1st, 2015, 9:23 pm / #23

Conversely of your coin, while installing your house security system is really a lot simpler right now than it turned out a few years previously, thanks on the proliferation involving high-quality instant components, it can be still a reasonably substantial project to setup a comprehensive system.Home Security

alsiah / October 1st, 2015, 9:24 pm / #24

It's a given that the market industry for affluent young people is enormous, and a large number of businesses over Britain commit many tens of thousands of pounds 12 months attracting thirty and thirty-something mothers and fathers and his or her offspring inside their particular organization.Playing Area

recuperar dados / October 15th, 2015, 8:08 am / #25

yeah nice to watch

mcx crude oil / October 26th, 2015, 11:24 pm / #26

I was taught that climate change comes from the sun. Yes, we are polluting this world big time. Mother earth should use centrifugal force to spin us all off the planet and give birth to new united creatures. We are definitely not an integrated group of people tied to a higher consciousness. We are a very psychologically sick group of people

ShavonneCovert / November 5th, 2015, 1:58 am / #27

Steam cleansing is particularly the most typically recounted technique for cleansing carpets. You will not need to utilize any cleaner. It is very simple to dispose of stains and dirt utilising steam Carpet Cleaning Woodland Hills. This works in a way that the water gets heated up to 200 levels and removes all of the germs.
This is why utilising natural and organic products to scrub these forms of rugs are advocated when it comes time to do away with and loosen very nearly any undesirable filth and debris out of your home. There are a number of systems for area Rug Cleaning Woodland Hills, and that you could be detailed you must accomplish that effectively by using studying forward.

Jerry / November 18th, 2015, 3:18 am / #28

The climate is changing. The earth is warming up, and there is now overwhelming scientific consensus that it is happening, and human-induced. With global warming on the increase and species and their habitats on the decrease, chances for ecosystems to adapt naturally are diminishing. United Nations need to look into this issue with all its seriousness. home plans in kerala

James / January 4th, 2016, 12:35 am / #29

Download Snapchat for PC(Freeware). Snapchat is the fastest way to share a moment with friends. You control how long your friends. snapchat free download

Nathaniel / January 4th, 2016, 12:36 am / #30

Finally now we can download and Install Tinder for PC easily? Installation recorded in a video to see it live as well explained step by step. tinder app download

Adidas adilette / January 18th, 2016, 11:44 pm / #31

I like to reading your blog post. Its informative for me and others.

wimbledonlive / May 11th, 2016, 4:41 am / #32

Your article is very good and helpful. You talk about right things. I always read your all articles. Thanks for this nice post

moksha / June 6th, 2016, 2:27 am / #33

MOKSHASTOCKS A Stock Market / Commodities Advisory Company , this company given MCX TIPS STOCKS TIPS,NCDEX TIPS ,COMEX TIPS

jkk / June 7th, 2016, 4:39 am / #34

With a device that allows for this method of cooking whether it be a Sous Vide stick or pan, you simply set the temperature to your cooking desired amount and drop the food into a vacuum sealed pouch and wait until it’s done. That is all you will need to do to cook utilizing this method. Home cooking blog

Frip / December 8th, 2016, 9:11 am / #36

Your information is good and friendly. article very helpful for me. Thank post.!

shiprabrock / December 9th, 2016, 2:29 am / #37

I have seen these mistakes made over and over again by people optimizing their websites to try and achieve a higher search engine ranking (Pagerank). In this article I go through some of the most common SEO mistakes and provide solutions to them. This article is targeted at broad Search Engine Optimisation advice for website owners, web designers or webmasters. SEO is not to be feared but embraced and I show you how to gain an edge.
plagiarism check

shiprabrock / February 8th, 2017, 9:44 pm / #38

wow, great, I was wondering how to cure acne naturally. and found your site by google, learned a lot, now i’m a bit clear. I’ve bookmark your site and also add rss. keep us updated.
soft and firm elements for sleep

imranuddin12302 / February 15th, 2017, 1:29 am / #39

What a good blog you have here. Please update it more often. This topics is my interest. Thank you. . .
jackets for men in Pakistan

Post a comment

Comments are closed for this post.